Sensitive Frustrations
Recently, I commented on a blog regarding openess in adoption. My comment stated that one of the reasons we adopted internationally was due to the fact that we didn't want to deal with the openness issue and how now, I am sad that Gabe will never have the chance to know his birth family. A later commenter somewhat responded to my comment to the effect that they wished they had a new pair of shoes for each time an international adopter expressed these same sentiments (paraphrased).
Ever since I read that I've been a bit miffed about the comment. As always I recognize that tone is hard to read so maybe the comment was harmless but it felt judgmental to me. I decided to write about it so that maybe it will stop bugging me. The purpose is not to attack the commenter.
We chose to adopt internationally for many, many reasons. When we initially began researching adoption, the plan was to adopt domestically. However, as we learned about the process we felt overwhelmed. The idea of openness, marketing ourselves, worrying about being chosen, no clear timeline, etc. was just too much with the pain of IF still so fresh. These initial reactions are what started us on the path of international. Once we really began looking at what we were OK with we decided the following:
1. We didn't feel the need to have a newborn. We did want a baby, but not necessarily a newborn.
2. We did not feel the need to have a child that matched our race.
3. Having already spent time in Guatemala, living with boarder families and in the remote villages, we felt we had a tie and strong appreciation for the culture.
4. We liked the fact that international adoptions had somewhat of a timeline (barring unforeseen changes).
5. There were babies there that needed families. (I know that this is also the case in the US as well).
6. International adoption felt right. Every time I thought about it, I became excited and hopeful. I did not feel the same excitement when I thought of adopting domestically.
There were many other reasons but these were the big ones. You see, it wasn't the openness issue that caused us to adopt internationally. It just happened to be one of the factors that started us looking in that direction in the first place. We were not being flip in our decision. There was a lot of blood, sweat, and tears that went into the decisions that we made. We recognized that these decisions did not only impact us, but any child that became part of our family. I do not regret our decision to adopt internationally at all. It was absolutely the right decision for this family, and I truly believe, for Gabriel.
I never, for even one moment, thought I could not deal with my future child's birth family. By that I mean, I would never disregard Gabe's feelings for them. I never planned to pretend like such feelings didn't exist. I was well aware of the fact that in order to be a good parent to Gabe, we would all have to be open and honest about his birth family. We were going to need to have clear, open lines of communication. I still haven't figured out the exact right way to honor them outwardly so that Gabe will always know how much they are valued by all of us. I think part of that will be a learning process as we go, but it will be. I think about Gabe's birth mother every day. I wonder how she is doing. I pray that she is healthy, that her employers are treating her well, that she feels at peace with her decision to release Gabe. I wish I could thank her and tell her I'm trying to be the very best mother I can be. It is amazing how we will always be connected even though all I have is a Polaroid picture of her. Her face is burned into my memory and always will be. I can also say with 100% certainty, that if Gabe ever wanted to try and find her, I would do my very best to help him. I would be there with him every step of the way.
What I have learned since Gabe's arrival home is that I would have eventually embraced an open adoption had we chosen the domestic route. However, we didn't choose that route, and in most international adoptions, it just isn't an option. No matter how much I wish it could be.
I guess what really frustrated me about this was that it felt like another case of feeling the need to justify the choices we made for our own family. I wish adoptive parents could bond together and support one another instead of judging each other.**
**This comment isn't directed at the above mentioned commenter. Like I said, it is hard to know tone on the internet. I did send her an e-mail but did not receive a response. That is fine, as a commenter on someone else's blog, she absolutely does not owe me a response.
Ever since I read that I've been a bit miffed about the comment. As always I recognize that tone is hard to read so maybe the comment was harmless but it felt judgmental to me. I decided to write about it so that maybe it will stop bugging me. The purpose is not to attack the commenter.
We chose to adopt internationally for many, many reasons. When we initially began researching adoption, the plan was to adopt domestically. However, as we learned about the process we felt overwhelmed. The idea of openness, marketing ourselves, worrying about being chosen, no clear timeline, etc. was just too much with the pain of IF still so fresh. These initial reactions are what started us on the path of international. Once we really began looking at what we were OK with we decided the following:
1. We didn't feel the need to have a newborn. We did want a baby, but not necessarily a newborn.
2. We did not feel the need to have a child that matched our race.
3. Having already spent time in Guatemala, living with boarder families and in the remote villages, we felt we had a tie and strong appreciation for the culture.
4. We liked the fact that international adoptions had somewhat of a timeline (barring unforeseen changes).
5. There were babies there that needed families. (I know that this is also the case in the US as well).
6. International adoption felt right. Every time I thought about it, I became excited and hopeful. I did not feel the same excitement when I thought of adopting domestically.
There were many other reasons but these were the big ones. You see, it wasn't the openness issue that caused us to adopt internationally. It just happened to be one of the factors that started us looking in that direction in the first place. We were not being flip in our decision. There was a lot of blood, sweat, and tears that went into the decisions that we made. We recognized that these decisions did not only impact us, but any child that became part of our family. I do not regret our decision to adopt internationally at all. It was absolutely the right decision for this family, and I truly believe, for Gabriel.
I never, for even one moment, thought I could not deal with my future child's birth family. By that I mean, I would never disregard Gabe's feelings for them. I never planned to pretend like such feelings didn't exist. I was well aware of the fact that in order to be a good parent to Gabe, we would all have to be open and honest about his birth family. We were going to need to have clear, open lines of communication. I still haven't figured out the exact right way to honor them outwardly so that Gabe will always know how much they are valued by all of us. I think part of that will be a learning process as we go, but it will be. I think about Gabe's birth mother every day. I wonder how she is doing. I pray that she is healthy, that her employers are treating her well, that she feels at peace with her decision to release Gabe. I wish I could thank her and tell her I'm trying to be the very best mother I can be. It is amazing how we will always be connected even though all I have is a Polaroid picture of her. Her face is burned into my memory and always will be. I can also say with 100% certainty, that if Gabe ever wanted to try and find her, I would do my very best to help him. I would be there with him every step of the way.
What I have learned since Gabe's arrival home is that I would have eventually embraced an open adoption had we chosen the domestic route. However, we didn't choose that route, and in most international adoptions, it just isn't an option. No matter how much I wish it could be.
I guess what really frustrated me about this was that it felt like another case of feeling the need to justify the choices we made for our own family. I wish adoptive parents could bond together and support one another instead of judging each other.**
**This comment isn't directed at the above mentioned commenter. Like I said, it is hard to know tone on the internet. I did send her an e-mail but did not receive a response. That is fine, as a commenter on someone else's blog, she absolutely does not owe me a response.
11 Comments:
This is frustrating, feeling like you have to justify your type of adoption, right? We've felt this, too, with our domestic adoption. And like you guys, we got started on a path based on fuzzy reasons, but once we were on it, we knew it was right. It's of course important to work these things out for yourself, but I don't think you owe anyone an explanation any more than a person who is fertile and gets pregnant has to explain or a person who decides not to have children at all. Cubbiegirl has said that adoption is just another family planning issue, and therefore not really anyone else's business.
However, how cool that you are willing to put it out there. I know a lot of potential adoptive parents read these blogs and it is helpful to see others work through the same stuff you are or are thinking through things that you will need to in the future. Thanks for writing this!
By
sster, at 10:10 AM
Well not to pick on the commentor, but she tends to pop in and say negative things. So I would take what she says with a grain of salt.
Also, you made an educated decision to go get your Gabe. It was your decision and no one elses. I'm sure your opinions/thoughts on other things related to parenting and adoption will shift as he grows older, so why not your feelings on the openness of your adoption?
I think you are doing great!
By
cubbiegirl, at 12:09 PM
I can understand your feelings. I so wish the birth mother of my baby could be available and share in her life growing up. I think it would make it a lot easier for my daughter to know that she was loved and not just "given away". I think about it all of the time. I know it isn't possible so I will try to establish a relationship with my daughter's foster mom. At least that will be some connection to her homeland (Guatemala).
All children, everywhere, need love and care. I hope you KNOW you don't have to justify your actions. Your personal decisions are nobody's business. I appreciate your sharing though.
By
Betsy, at 5:04 PM
I completely understand your feelings and have had many similar thoughts myself. Unfortunately with any type of adoption there is no "perfect" situation, whether it is a domestic open adoption or an international adoption. There are pros and cons to both and you made an educated decision and most importantly you chose the path that felt right for you!
I myself find that certain things people ask or say regarding our adoption choice can really rub me the wrong way, even though I know they didn't mean anything by it. Try not to let one particular comment upset you, though I know that's easier said than done! That being said, I sincerely appreciate this open and honest post. It makes me feel so much better to know that I am not alone in feeling the way I do! Thank you for sharing!
By
Kristin, at 10:33 PM
Okay, I posted a really long, sensitive comment on this last night, but our internet is acting goofy with the ice and all. So, in summary: I totally agree with you. The decision to adopt, including from where a couple adopts, is highly personal. It is a decision between the couple/individual adopting and a qualified social worker.
Adoption is a family planning decision and those choices deserve the privacy and respect any other couple would enjoy.
Thanks for this post. It's an important topice.
By
Erin, at 9:45 AM
Even though we are still not that far into the process, I have still already gotten a few comments from people that I haven't really...umm...appreciated. I know there was no harm meant...but still.
I totally agree with that most of your other commenters have said here...it's a personal decision. I don't really understand where the judgement is coming from. :(
By
Tiff, at 10:30 AM
when we first started the process, we were all gung ho on international - and we pursued that route first. if the program hadn't disintegrated, we would have adopted internationally. so we came to domestic by default. but once we were in it, we knew that it was the right choice for us. and now, looking at our second, we went back and forth with international versus domestic and ended up choosing domestic because of knowing our child's birthfamily and because it's just plain easier for us. but i still think that someday we'll adopt internationally. i really want to experience both - they both have so many great things about them!
By
afrindiemum, at 4:20 PM
Kim I think that you and Ben make amazing parents and there should be no reason for you to ever have to justify adopting Gabe. You and Ben both have done so many great things in a way you've been like parents to me. You both have always been there when I've needed someone try not to let these people get to you, because this is what god wanted, and he's never wrong. I love you.
By
Cassie, at 1:57 PM
Thanks for posting this - As someone who is researching international adoption (Guatemala, specifically), I appreciate the insight.
By
erinberry, at 4:19 PM
I did send you a response you must not have recieved it. My comments are not negative they are just positive towards natural families. If you are truly secure in what you are doing then you won't object to somebody having a different viewpoint to you. You did say in your original comment that you chose international adoption so that you wouldn't have to deal with his family. And now that it is virtually impossible to have contact you can say what a pity that is. I woulndn't take what I say with a grain of salt, I would just see it as a view from someone who has a different perspective to you. And in my e-mail back to you I did explain that it certainly was not meant as a personal attack.
If you can find the mother of the child you adopted that would be wonderful, I hope you are true to your words and will strive to make contact with his family. Wishing you all a wonderful Christmas.
By
sarahmariah, at 11:54 AM
This what what you said":
"One of the reasons we did not pursue a domestic adoption was because we didn't want to deal with open adoption issues".
It seems that so many adults want to tailor make adoption to suit their wants and needs and forget about what is in the best interests of the child. Adoption should never be about making infertile people parents, it should always be about what is best for the child.
I am much gladdened to hear that you are now wanting to have contact with his family and wish you all the best with finding them and establishing a positive relationship.
By
sarahmariah, at 2:00 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home